Share this article:
Print

Animal control mistakenly euthanizes family's dogs

Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

by TONY BURBECK / NewsChannel 36
E-mail Tony: TBurbeck@WCNC.com

WCNC.com

Posted on March 3, 2010 at 7:08 PM

Updated Thursday, Mar 4 at 8:32 AM

CHARLOTTE, N.C. -- Charlotte-Mecklenburg Animal Care and Control mistakenly euthanized a family's dogs and is now conducting an internal investigation to figure out what went wrong.

"They just murdered my dogs for no reason," said Will Harlee.

Harlee has several pictures and videotapes of his dogs Ralow and Deuce. In one videotape, Ralow is wrestling with Harlee on a bed. In another video, Ralow is playing with Harlee's infant daughter.

Ralow, a 9-year-old pit bull mix, loved sleeping on pillows.

"Prettiest dog you'd ever see," said Harlee.

A picture of Deuce shows Harlee's son riding on the pit bull's back.

"He would even let the kids walk him," Harlee said.

They were family.

"They were just like two kids. They just wanted to play," Harlee said.

Ralow and Deuce crawled through a hole in their fenced backyard last week and wandered away. Animal Care and Control picked them up.

Ralow got loose years ago and had a hold on him if found again, Animal Care and Control officials said.

Animal Care and Control paperwork says Harlee could get his dogs back once he fixed the fence. Harlee made the repairs. But when he arrived at Animal Care and Control, he found out the dogs were dead.

"'I'm sorry Mr. Harlee, but your dogs have been euthanized,'" Harlee said, recalling what he was told.

Animal Care and Control apologized. Harlee said employees told him, "It's a mistake. No one knows what happened."

Harlee said he cried in front of his children, who still thought Ralow and Deuce were alive.

"I couldn't even open the door," he said.

Now, Harlee says Animal Care and Control needs to be held accountable for its mistake, and he still has questions without answers.

"I need to know why and who," he said. "I want somebody to lose their job over this. I need an impression that this can't happen to anybody else."

"We're going to look at things very carefully because it does concern us and it's not something we're going to sweep under the rug," said Melissa Knicely with Animal Care and Control. "So it's important to us to make sure things are handled properly."

Animal Care and Control says it didn't hear from the Harlees for a couple of days and say the fence wasn't fixed when they stopped by. Harlee says he didn't fix it immediately because it was raining.

Animal Care and Control says it's working on better communication.

Share this article:
Print

To add a comment, please register or login.

Leave your comment
1000 characters remaining

Submit

We welcome your comments on this story's topic. Off-topic comments, personal attacks, and inappropriate language may be flagged and removed, and comment privileges blocked, per our Terms of Service. Thanks for keeping the comments space respectful.

Privacy Policy

HTML is not allowed.

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Comments: Displaying 1 - 15 of 33

kissmyss2010 said on March 18, 2010 at 4:12 PM

macmaynne: you are one funny ignorant character! i have a wonderful husband and a beautiful son plus two of the most loving and loyal and respectable pitbulls on this planet. i can sympathize with this family b/c i understand what they are going through. i see my pitbulls as part of my family and not as "wild animals". i respect them and treat them like dogs and they have shown nothing but obedience and love to me and my family. i think it's hilarious what comes out of your mouth and you sound like a child. how about YOU get a life and move on! if you don't care about this subject that go F*@k yourself.

39551447
Flag this comment

sanfran said on March 9, 2010 at 2:46 AM

Hi tamharlee, If Animal Care and Control said that they euthanized a dog named "Hannah", does that mean that there is a chance that Deuce is still at the shelter and alive? Did you ask them about that?

38906886
Flag this comment

fawxfyre1 said on March 5, 2010 at 1:05 PM

My heart totally goes out to this family! Such heartbreak that is not soon to go away, while in a lot of cases, the shelter's employees only get a slap on the wrist! I along with hundreds of other animal activists are working to end tragedies such as this! In my opinion, there is NO EXCUSE! There are more and more animal lovers/activists banding together to get changes made in this country. We realize it is a long, slow process, but we will not stop until these type of people are made accountable! Many prayers go out to this family at this time; Keep your faith that change will come. Your babies will not have died in vain!! May they both RIP "in the arms of an angel", and "may they find some comfort there".

38735181
Flag this comment

nikkip said on March 5, 2010 at 2:06 AM

Macmaynne, I would say that based on the number of responses to this story, that you are wrong. People do care. I care. I hope that with this last response to your ignorance in general and disrespect to the family overall that no one else will respond to your tirades and give you any more attention. My condolences to the Harlee family and good luck with getting any help from Animal Control. It will be a long fight. I do know how much that you love your pets, I feel the same way. If this happened to one of mine I would want retribution as well. Just remember to keep the good times you had with your pets in your memories and close to your heart. That will help you in the days ahead.

38711088
Flag this comment

macmaynne said on March 4, 2010 at 10:35 PM

I killed a fly today. The fly has feelings, I'm a murderer, there should be an investigation. Let's give the fly a funeral "he was a good fly, flew around alot." Let's put this on the news, "Major break in the fly slaying case." LMAO! Do you know how rediculous some of you sound? It's an animal, not a person. If you need something to love that bad, get a man/woman, have kids, go mentor a child. Human safety is more important than some lonely person wanting to keep wild animals as pets. There's no 'murder' investigation, noone is going to lose their job over this, because the reality is that most normal people have more important things to worry about, real problems. Noone cares. Get over it. Get a life.

38703633
Flag this comment

abercrombielucie said on March 4, 2010 at 8:50 PM

Tamharlee- I am so sorry for your loss. Animals can truly become family members. I had a pit bull mix when I was growing up. The Sweetest and smartest dog I've ever known. She even was a surrogate mother to an abandoned litter of Lab puppies. You and your family are in my thoughts and prayers.

38699041
Flag this comment

tamharlee said on March 4, 2010 at 7:11 PM

My husband also has a client that authorized them to spay and neuter her dogs...she said it was a male and female (non-pittbull). She said she was there the entire process and also showed up and was advised that hers were mistakenly put to sleep. She said she didnt believe it and made them show her. They took her to the freezer. We asked why she didnt report it and she said she didnt know what to do. This has happened in the past but has probably been swept under the rug. For the people that think they are such aggressive animals, listen to me when i tell you from a puppy i watch Ralow and looked for all the things i had heard. I even told my husband that "If i ever say hint of aggression towards the kids, i wouldnt hesitate to end his life" I now know better and learned that the pet will take care of you as long as you take care of it. The AC have on paper that they euthanized Hannah she was a Shih Tzu, but made more noise than Ralow. So the breed in this case doesnt matter!

38694016
Flag this comment

jilliebean9700 said on March 4, 2010 at 4:33 PM

tamharlee-i am so very sorry for your family's loss. i would be devastated if the same happened to my pugs. my condolences. macmaynne- you are very cold and heartless. dogs are NOT just possessions to true pet lovers. they become part of your family. mine are like my children. a family has lost their beloved pets and you are being hateful. it is uncalled for.

38683473
Flag this comment

jackdog said on March 4, 2010 at 4:30 PM

dlenn, the best protection for your AmStaff is to be the most responsible, knowledgeable owner you can be. Regardless of breed, ALL DOGS should be closely supervised and safely contained. This means a 6-foot fence around the area where the dog is allowed to go outside, under supervision. When you are not home, your dog should be contained inside, preferably in a crate. That way, your dog cannot get loose from the yard and it cannot cause harm to your home or property. Your dog should get rigorous daily exercise and be securely leashed whenever off of your property. Establish pack structure with your dog via obedience training, particularly to the tune of "Nothing In Life is Free." (google it) The first, second, and third rules of owning a dog of ANY breed are 'personal responsibility.' If you would like more bully-specific tips from a really great online community dedicated to bully breeds, check out the pit bull chat forum at www.pitbull-chat.com.

38683213
Flag this comment

manthala said on March 4, 2010 at 3:55 PM

Family dogs RALOW and DEUCE were euthanized because of a mistake. This is the story given by Charlotte Mecklenburg Police Department Animal Care and Control. They were picked up on February 22, euthanized on February 26. By mistake. We are told an internal investigation is underway. RALOW and DEUCE were Pit Bulls. Family dogs. Kept inside. RALOW was nine years old. Figures are there, internally [ last fiscal year, this fiscal year/ year-to-date] for the numbers of dogs — non Pit Bull and Pit Bull mix dogs and Pit Bull and Pit Bull mix dogs — confiscated by CMPD AC&C for containment issues. Figures are there, internally, regarding how long these dogs were housed at CMPD Animal Care and Control until and if the owners were able to reclaim. Figures are there, internally, regarding what fines were charged the owners who were able to reclaim their dogs. One can easily surmise how long some dogs are held pending owner reclaim by looking at the fees.

38680606
Flag this comment

southcharlotte said on March 4, 2010 at 3:51 PM

Animal Control made a mistake - but the family was hardly "owner of the year!" Knowing all the details of the care - the reason he couldn't just reclaim the dogs is because they had been such a nuisance in the past they were under confinment orders, they weren't current on all shots/licenses, etc. If the family had never had any previous issues with their "angel dogs" than they simply would have gone to the shelter, picked up their strays and been done with it. There is always more to it than the "victim" is going to let on. Now that someone else screwed up (and gave him a cash windfall) he becomes a saint and everyone else the devil. While Animal Control may have made a mistake - good dog owners don't lose their animals and they certainly aren't on a "do not reclaim" list at the shelter!

38680308
Flag this comment

dogmama8 said on March 4, 2010 at 3:51 PM

This makes me so ill. First, to the family who lost their dogs (babies really) God Bless you during this time. I an only imagine the pain you are going through. Secondly, the ignorance I am reading here is appalling. Dogs, when well cared for ( as it seems these two were) are the most loving and loyal of friends. They protect your children, your home, and your life if you ask them to. All they ask in return is food, water, and love. I understand the strain on Animal Care's resources, but they are guilty of murder here and should be held accountable. Everyone from the shelter manager to the Vet who administered the lethal injection should be SACKED immediately. Anyone who has ever had a dog knows that sometimes they don't listen and sometimes they can even get away from you, and you can only hope that a good samaritan or the people who work for the city in which you live will treat your animals with kindness. There is a special place waiting for those who mistreat man's best friend.

38680303
Flag this comment

dlenn said on March 4, 2010 at 3:27 PM

Jackdog- I would love to find a reputable trainer for my AmStaff. Every time I read an article like this it scares the crud out of me. What if my baby got loose and something happened? When he is outside, he is on a lead in the fenced yard, but I can't guarantee he won't get out even after all the precautions I take. Do you have any recommendations?

38678493
Flag this comment

jackdog said on March 4, 2010 at 1:56 PM

tamharlee, I am so sorry for you and your family's loss. This strikes right at home for me, because I have an American Staffordshire and a Doberman mix. They've gotten out a few times, and I've been lucky enough to catch them right away, but what happened to your sweet Ralow and Deuce lives in my nightmares. This sort of thing happens all the time to pit bulls, but not so much to other breeds. Please disregard the haters who will tell you that they're 'just dogs' or they're inherently a 'vicious breed.' I'm so, so , so sorry for your family's loss. Please consider adopting or rescuing more sweet bully breeds as a legacy to the two that you lost, and to thumb your noses at everyone here who doesn't understand. I've been training dogs for more than 20 years, guide dogs and more advance personal protection work, and I am now a 'pit bull' owner for life. These dogs are so sensitive, gentle, and responsive, as well as athletic, intelligent and very, very trainable.

38671468
Flag this comment

suburbandharma said on March 4, 2010 at 1:54 PM

There are indeed people who are irresponsible about their dogs. And equally as many (likely far more) who are irresponsible with their children. And children who are raised poorly are far more apt to become a danger to society than an animal with the barest of needs and no knowledge of ego or jealousy. For example, those people apparently become postal carriers... and we all know how that sometimes turns out! :P (must be the dogs' fault...) In any case, even if you don't support the owners of dogs in general, Animal Control dropped the ball and consequences are in order. Personal responsibility is a scarcity these days and the bottom line is this: If you mess up this big, you should lose your job, period.

38671276
Flag this comment

totaljett said on March 4, 2010 at 1:41 PM

The shouldn't have gotten loose in the first place, period. Reason why I stopped delivering mail. Dog owners can be so irresponsible and trust me they don't care. I maced every dog that came my way believe that. As for the," they're like children statement" they're not! It kills me when people compare dogs to being children Such a statment should be a mandatory back hand slap to reality. What everyone should be saying is thank goodness a child was not mauled or killed while these dogs were loose. It goes to show how disturbing people have prioritized dogs. Trust me, this guy wouldn't shed a tear if someone's child was mauled or killed by his dogs. Think about that before you think this outcome was so sad.

38670321
Flag this comment

iamace said on March 4, 2010 at 1:19 PM

Hey Macmynne: Umm if dogs should be outlawed then so should cats. I think cats and oh wait birds...oh wait ALL ANIMAL LIFE...wait that will include HUMANS too We are the Naked Ape! If you can sit there and say that dogs have no feelings, then why do they show agression? Agression is a feeling. If dogs cannot have any feelings according to you the how are they dangerous?

38668471
Flag this comment

bungmal10 said on March 4, 2010 at 12:48 PM

macmaynne People like you are exactly what is wrong with this world. People kill more people daily than dogs do in a year.

38665741
Flag this comment

ds001 said on March 4, 2010 at 12:32 PM

macmaynne. 0/10

38664371
Flag this comment

macmaynne said on March 4, 2010 at 11:56 AM

It's a dog! I don't care and animal control don't care. Get over it and get another one. Booo hooooo some thing that only eats and craps was killed. Good. People over pets. Animal control was called for a reason. Dogs are dangerous. They attack people all the time. It is a threat to society (and I do say it because it is not human and has no 'feelings'). If it were up to me they would be outlawed.

38661246
Flag this comment

suburbandharma said on March 4, 2010 at 11:20 AM

Oops... sorry, I forgot that Animal Control refused to release the dogs until repairs were completed... my apologies. Best of luck to the family.

38658286
Flag this comment

suburbandharma said on March 4, 2010 at 11:08 AM

This senseless euthanization is inexusable. I hope the owners will research pit bull rescue groups, animal rescue attorneys, and celebrities who can provide publicity to this cause, and not stop until something is done and someone at least learns from this. (I attempted to post suggestions but that's not allowed) Policy needs to be created or changed to prevent this from ever happening to anyone's family members again. It's a shame the owners couldn't rely on the information given over the phone- people who don't understand the importance of family pets should absolutely not be working at Animal Control. I would question, however, why the dogs weren't brought home and let out on-leash only for a few days until the fence was repaired. That said, I sincerely hope the family finds representation and successfully files a suit against Animal Control.

38657296
Flag this comment

iamace said on March 4, 2010 at 10:33 AM

Hey Justdoit, I sure hope you can prove your kid did not taunt the dog. Three years ago I watched as a kid taunted a very large (three times the kids size) Boxer who was as nice and loving as any well cared for dog. If I had not yelled at the kid to stop and told him to go get his mom to come talk to me, he would have been bitten. The dog was getting really agitated by the taunting and his too short of a fence would not have kept him back were it not for him minding me. Oh and I got all this on my security camera. I would have helped the dogs owners instead of the kids parents any day!

38654401
Flag this comment

justdoit said on March 4, 2010 at 10:25 AM

Yea this is sad but these dogs are unperdictable, owners need to make sure they are secured when they are lft. alone. they could turn aggressive in a finger snap. kids getting of the school bus and you have a pit bull or any dog running around , because they got loose by mistake. I pray that my kids never be attacked by a dog because the owner will pay for it dearly..

38653746
Flag this comment

iamace said on March 4, 2010 at 9:58 AM

It appears the Harlees did everything right. The dogs were not even considered dangerous. What is riduculous is the fact that people feel they need to comment on a story such as this in a negative way. To Macmaynne, these dogs are not wild. If you paid attention in school you would know that humans domesticated the dog to assist us. We owe dogs much more than we give them. Duece and Ralow should not be forgotten. Be they Pit Bulls or Poodles, dogs are only what WE make them. If WE cast them out into the cold they should be cold to us. But, that is not the dogs way. It will come back to you for the love it craves and will give you so much more love than anything thing or any one else can. In my house we have five cats who tolerate us, two dogs who love us almost to death and five rabbits who are really just as confused at the menagerie as we are. Char-Meck needs a no-kill policy! Spay and Neuter your dogs!

38651813
Flag this comment

tamharlee said on March 4, 2010 at 9:58 AM

jessthemom- you are just as ignorant as some of the others..that daughter is now 9 and grew up with Ralow. They were the same age(not dog years). Ralow also had no teeth and could not have harmed a flee. These were house bound pets and the extensive rain made the boards week on the fence. This is the same fence that has been approved by AC before. These dogs instantly have a bad reputation at birth and should not be stereotyped. They are no different than any other breed and were so spoiled that they didnt like to even go outside...Please do your research before you make rude comments, because you obviously dont have a clue! They have a process that they didnt follow it... bottom line and they lied and said we could repair the fence once the rain stopped(3 days). The repair order was given on Tuesday and the repairman came out on friday and rebuit the fence.

38651801
Flag this comment

jessthemom said on March 4, 2010 at 9:46 AM

This story makes me mad. Blame animal control? How about you blame yourself dude. YOU are the one who kept your dogs outside unchained with a fence that had a hole. YOU put the whole neighborhood at risk by allowing your pitbulls to escape and run around unattended. YOU are the one who chose not to fix your fence right away and left the dogs to be taken care of by animal control (with society's tax dollars!) AND seeing that he let his infant daughter play with this dog, animal control probably just saved her life. Thank you animal control.

38651003
Flag this comment

tamharlee said on March 4, 2010 at 9:42 AM

The point is when my husband spoke to them on 02/23, the supervisor advised that he had a hold on the dogs until the repairs were completed. My husband advised it would take a couple of days to get someone out because of all the rain and asked how long we had. The supervisor said we didnt have a time. He went on to explain that we would be responsible for a $10 per day boarding fee per dog. We took his word. And now they are gone!

38650673
Flag this comment

tamharlee said on March 4, 2010 at 9:37 AM

To (macmaynne), if you do not care for the story. Do not read it. The shelter fabricated a story to cover up what they did! Our oldest dog Ralow has had a chip for several years and we should have been notified per there process when they were picked up..My husband drove for 5 hours because everytime he called the shelter, they said they were not there. It wasnt until we went there to look for ourselves that we found them...they had been there since that morning. Also, our dogs are housebound at least 20 hours a day and had only been outside a couple of hours when they got out. Let me remind you also that the second dog (Deuce) had never been to the pound let alone gotten out of the fence. it was his first time there and when they told us, they said " We are sorry, we euthanized Ralow and Hannah". The other dogs name was Deuce , so the didnt even know the dog that they were killing.

38650383
Flag this comment

macmaynne said on March 4, 2010 at 6:48 AM

Who cares? It's a wild animal, not a person. If the family cared enough about the dog, they would have controlled it and it wouldn't have gone to animal contol in the first place. If they're not going to take care of the dog, then they shouldn't have it in the first place. We have more important things to worry about than some lonely person whining because they need something to love. Absolutely rediculous story.

38644146
Flag this comment

oldseadog said on March 3, 2010 at 11:20 PM

gut wrenching and sickening to have a loved pet euthanised for no reason, pure callousness, the only excuse is there are so many animals that euthanasis is the only answer and so those who must put an animal down get hardened to what they do...the only real answer for the animal control is to get a law passed to have pets spayed or neutered so there isn't that many to deal with unless its a pure bred for show purposes and for breeding and for owners to make certain their pet does not get out to run loose and always on a leash when outdoors, always make sure a fence is secure and no holes to get through and like any child in a yard, check frequently to see they are where they are suppose to be..i too grieve for that family, it truly is a tragedy, perhaps a law requiring all dogs to have a chip so that it can be scanned if the dog gets loose can be returned...

38634348
Flag this comment

abercrombielucie said on March 3, 2010 at 10:54 PM

This is so horrible. My heart completely goes out to this family. I have a boxer mix and a doberman. And if for ANY reason this happened to me I was sue them so fast. This is so unforgivable. And I am sure if this was small breed dog as opposed to a Pit Bull this wouldn't have happened. Inexcusable. Someone better lose their job over this.

38633131
Flag this comment

cherokee627 said on March 3, 2010 at 10:33 PM

this seems to run rampant in many places. a neighbor's extremely friendly puppy pit bull (probably no more than about 8 months old) slipped off his collar. his owner and her son went immediately to the shelter and were cited for not having the proper shots and were told they could not pick up the puppy until they could pay the fees which were over $300. by the end of the week when my neighbor received her paycheck they had already euthanized her dog. she was told they didn't know when she would be back and couldn't hold him any longer. of course they had her name address and phone number but couldn'te bothered to call and verify when she would come back. i believe it was because the dog was a pit bull.

38632183
Flag this comment